Our St. John Real Estate Agency and Agents

Cruz Bay Realty, Inc. is a second generation, family owned real estate company serving St. John since 1985. We take pride in our reputation, integrity, and understanding of the real estate market on St. John. Whether you are looking for the ideal island property to purchase, or you are trying to make a decision about selling, you can rely on the professional team at Cruz Bay Realty, Inc. to give you accurate and informed advice and information.

GRETCHEN LABRENZ is the principal broker and president of her family’s real estate company. Originally from Columbus, Ohio, where she attended Ohio State University, she has lived on St. John since 1981. She worked at Caneel Bay Resort for 10 years prior to joining the family business. Gretchen’s dedication, unique background, knowledge, outstanding reputation, and expertise in the St. John real estate market has made her one of St. John’s top producing brokers!  Gretchen has served as a director of the St. John Board of Realtors, Pine Peace School, and the Villa Caribe and Point Rendezvous Home Owners Association.

Order a copy of Gretchen’s Island cookbook “St. John Style”

MARGARET LABRENZ serves as office manager and has a wealth of real estate knowledge and “living on St. John” information to offer. She and her late husband, Jim Labrenz, relocated to St. John from Ohio in 1977 and founded Cruz Bay Realty in 1985. They built the first house in Estate Fish Bay, appropriately called “Goodbye Columbus.” Subsequently, they built two more homes in Fish Bay, then constructed their Klein Bay home where Margaret currently resides. Margaret is very active in community affairs, is the past president of the St. John Historical Society, charter member of the St. John Board of Realtors, St. John Singers, Director of Klein Bay Homeowners Association and a member of Audubon Society and St. John AARP.

View Margie’s rental property “On the Rocks”

AMANDA ARQUIT, originally from Jacksonville, Florida, Amanda graduated from the University of North Florida. She fulfilled her dream of moving to St. John and quickly immersed herself in all the island had to offer. Initial positions in hospitality management led her to aid in the relocation of an array of guests. This fueled her decision to pursue further knowledge and licensing in real estate. Amanda is now an active member of the St. John Board of Realtors and honored to serve as the 2016 President Elect.  In her free time you can find her surfing, paddle boarding, scuba diving, or hiking. Her caring and accommodating nature makes her well liked by clients and customers alike. Amanda is eager to meet you, and help you discover your own slice of paradise!


SUSANNE KIRK, a Peter Bay property owner since 1994, has the experience to help you navigate the upscale St. John real estate market to make win-win transactions for both buyers and sellers. Susanne is committed to providing quality service, along with extensive knowledge of building, renting and market trends. Originally from Wilmington, Ohio, Susanne earned her Ph.D. in education and was a college professor at Xavier University in Cincinnati before making St. John her home. Susanne serves as the chair of the Peter Bay Architectural Review Board, as well as a board member of the St. John Animal Care Center and is involved in other community service organizations.

View Susanne’s luxury rental property, “Villa La Susa”